Here is a situation that happens in almost every Baseball5 game. There’s a runner on second base. The ball is hit, the runner rounds third, and for a split second they have to decide: stop, or keep going for home?
Most runners make that decision on gut feeling. I did too, for many years. But while preparing the Danish National Team for the 2025 European Championship, I started asking a different question. What do I give up if I stop at third?
Stopping at third isn’t “giving up”
In baseball, stopping at third can feel like a missed opportunity. In Baseball5 it is often the opposite, because a runner on third base is extremely valuable.
From close to 12,000 at bats of European Baseball5, this is how often the runner on third scored on the very next play:
| Outs | Runner on third scores on the next play |
|---|---|
| 0 outs | 78.5% |
| 1 out | 77.3% |
| 2 outs | 47.8% |
So if you stop at third with zero outs, you still have roughly an 80% chance of scoring on the next hitter’s play, and that’s without any risk to yourself on this play.
That gives us a simple way to think about the decision. You should only go for home if your chance of making it is at least as good as the chance you’d have by stopping.
The rule
When I worked through the numbers, it came out as three easy-to-remember thresholds for a runner on second base thinking about going all the way home:
- 80 – With zero outs: only go if you are about 80% sure you’ll make it. If you stop at third, you’ll most likely score anyway, with one out and a runner on third. Getting thrown out at home turns a great situation into nothing.
- 50 – With one out: go if it’s about a 50/50 chance. If you stay at third and the hitter is out, you are now a runner on third with two outs, and that runner only scores about half the time.
- 20 – With two outs: be aggressive. If you stop at third, you need the next hitter to reach base safely without the defense making a force out, or the inning is over. So the real question is “how likely is the next hitter to get on base?”. At the European Championship I used the batting average of my weakest hitter, around .200, as a baseline. That’s where the 20 comes from.
I like to say that with zero outs we protect our momentum, with one out we find our balance, and with two outs we embrace the chaos.
Make it your own
The 80/50/20 rule is not gospel. It’s a practical tool that’s easy to remember when the game is moving fast. A few things should make you adjust it:
- Who is on deck? With two outs and your best hitter coming up, you might take the safer third base and trust them to bring you home. The runner on third still scores about half the time with two outs.
- The score and the inning. Down by one in the last inning is not the same as up by four in the second.
- Your players. These are averages from many teams. If your runners or your opponent’s arms are clearly above or below average, move the numbers.
If percentages don’t work for your players, translate it into words:
- Zero outs: be very sure before you go.
- One out: you can gamble a little.
- Two outs: be aggressive on close plays, unless a really strong hitter is up next.
Why I like rules of thumb
You can’t bring a spreadsheet onto the basepaths. But players can carry a simple idea with them, and a simple idea that is built on data beats a gut feeling built on habits from another sport. My hope is that rules like this one help players understand why a decision is right, so the decision eventually becomes instinct.
Sources
- Spielmann, P. (2026). Round It! – Data-Driven Baseball5 Baserunning. Chapter 2 (“The 80/50/20 Rule”), including the probability of the runner on third base scoring, based on close to 12,000 at bats across the 2023 European Championship, the 2024 Youth European Championship and the 2024 World Cup.
Want to go deeper?
The 80/50/20 rule is one of the most practical tools I have come up with, and it’s only one part of the baserunning picture. If you want to dig into the data behind it, start with Round It! – Data-Driven Baseball5 Baserunning.
You can find all my books on my Buy my books page and on Amazon (.com / .de). They are also available as audiobooks on Spotify. If you have Spotify Premium, audiobook listening time is included in the subscription in many countries. The audiobooks don’t have the graphs and tables, but all the main ideas are there.
If you would rather talk it through, I offer one-on-one coaching sessions and a strategy discussion course for coaches and teams. Get in touch or write to me at Show email. I’m always happy to talk Baseball5.

