Why I Share Everything I Find About Baseball5

Every now and then someone asks me why I publish everything. The data, the matrices, the lineup tools, the strategies I use with the Danish National Team. Wouldn’t it be smarter to keep it to myself? Isn’t that my edge?

It’s a fair question, and I want to answer it properly.

The game we are trying to grow

Baseball5 has just made its debut on the Olympic stage at the Youth Olympic Games in Dakar. That is a huge moment for a sport that was only launched by the WBSC less than ten years ago. But a youth debut is not the same as a permanent place in the Olympic programme. For that, Baseball5 has to look like a sport that is played at a high level everywhere, not just by a handful of countries.

And right now, that isn’t always what you see.

At international tournaments I have watched games end with lopsided scores like 20–0. When I watch those games closely, it rarely looks like one team is twenty runs more athletic than the other. More often, one team simply knows things the other team doesn’t. Where to hit with runners on first and second. Which base to throw to with one out. When a runner should stop at third. Small pieces of knowledge, but they add up quickly in a five-inning game.

When a decision-maker from the Olympic world watches a game like that, they don’t see “a team that lacks information”. They see a sport that doesn’t look ready.

Gatekeeping hurts the whole sport

I understand why teams protect their knowledge. Competition is competition, and everybody wants to win. I want to win too.

But I believe that in a young sport, gatekeeping information works against all of us. If only a few teams play at an elite level, Baseball5 will look like a niche activity. If every team plays at a high level, with smart hitting, sound defense and real tactics, then Baseball5 looks like what it actually is: a fast, intense, professional sport that deserves a place among the big ones.

My edge as a coach shouldn’t come from my opponents not knowing the basics. If my team wins, I want it to be because we executed better on the day. Not because the other team never had the chance to learn.

Why it started with data

When I started analysing Baseball5, I had three reasons, and I wrote them down in my first book:

  1. To give the Danish National Team an edge in our preparation.
  2. To contribute to raising the level of play.
  3. To help new coaches become better coaches, so that more players become better players.

Reasons two and three are the reason everything is public. I spent hundreds of hours watching games on WBSC’s YouTube channel and entering play-by-play data into spreadsheets. That knowledge isn’t worth much if it stays in my spreadsheets.

There is also a more personal reason. I’m a big fan of Stephen Covey’s 7 Habits of Highly Effective People, and of the eighth habit he later added: leaving a legacy. That idea speaks to me. If my small contribution helps a coach in a country where Baseball5 is brand new avoid a 20–0 loss and fall in love with the game instead, then the work was worth it.

Baseball5 needs its own knowledge

There is one more reason sharing matters so much right now. Many of us came to Baseball5 from baseball or softball, and we naturally bring that knowledge with us. A lot of it helps. But as I have shown in my books, a lot of the fundamental dynamics of Baseball5 are different:

  • A runner on second base is not in scoring position the way it is in baseball.
  • Double plays are much rarer, so “get two” is a much weaker defensive plan.
  • The more forced runners there are, the harder it gets to hit yourself on base.
  • The lineup works differently when it is only five hitters long.

If we just copy baseball thinking, teams will overvalue some decisions and undervalue others. And teams without a baseball background often have no reference point at all. The only way the whole sport gets better quickly is if what we learn about Baseball5 itself is shared openly, discussed, criticized and improved.

That last part matters to me as well. I don’t publish my findings because I think they are final. I publish them because I want people to test them, find my mistakes and build something better on top. Some of my own conclusions have already been corrected by later data, sometimes on my own and sometimes after questions from readers.

What I hope you do with it

If you coach a team, take what is useful, ignore what isn’t, and share what you find with the coach of the team you just played against. If you are a player, ask your coach why you do what you do. And if you disagree with something I’ve written, tell me. That conversation is exactly how this sport grows up.

The Olympic dream for Baseball5 isn’t something one country can earn alone. We earn it together, by making every game worth watching.

Sources

  • Spielmann, P. (2025). A Runner on 2B Is Not in Scoring Position… …and Why You Should Care. Chapter 1 (“Why you shouldn’t think baseball”) and Chapter 15 (conclusion).
  • Spielmann, P. (2026). Who’s Up? – The Art of Creating an Effective Lineup in Baseball5. Chapter 12 (conclusion).
  • Covey, S. R. (1989). The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People. Simon & Schuster.
  • Olympics.com: Dakar 2026: The four sports making their Youth Olympic Games debut

Want to go deeper?

Everything I have found so far is written down, tables and all. If you want to dig into the data behind it, start with A Runner on 2B Is Not in Scoring Position… …and Why You Should Care, Who’s Up? – The Art of Creating an Effective Lineup in Baseball5 and Round It! – Data-Driven Baseball5 Baserunning.

You can find all my books on my Buy my books page and on Amazon (.com / .de). They are also available as audiobooks on Spotify. If you have Spotify Premium, audiobook listening time is included in the subscription in many countries. The audiobooks don’t have the graphs and tables, but all the main ideas are there.

If you would rather talk it through, I offer one-on-one coaching sessions and a strategy discussion course for coaches and teams. Get in touch or write to me at Show email. I’m always happy to talk Baseball5.